Value Investing and Long-Term Wealth Creation in Australia

Why buying quality businesses below intrinsic value — and holding patiently — remains the most reliable path to superior long-term investment returns for Australian investors.

Chess strategy as a metaphor for disciplined long-term value investing

What Is Value Investing?

Value investing is the practice of buying securities — typically shares in listed companies — at prices materially below their estimated intrinsic value. It was systematised by Benjamin Graham in the 1930s and 1940s, popularised by Warren Buffett, and has since produced a long and distinguished lineage of successful practitioners around the world, including in Australia.

The core logic is simple: if you can reliably buy a dollar's worth of business for seventy cents, and hold it patiently until the market recognises the full value, you will outperform over time. The challenge — and it is substantial — lies in the analysis, the discipline and the patience required to execute this approach consistently.

At Leyland, value investing is not just one input into our process — it is the foundation of everything we do. Since 2003, it has guided our approach to private wealth management, SMSF management, and family office services for our clients across Australia.

Why Value Investing Works: The Academic and Empirical Evidence

The evidence for value investing's long-term superiority is extensive and spans markets, time periods and economic regimes.

Academic research — from Graham and Dodd's original work through to Fama and French's famous factor studies — consistently shows that companies trading at low price-to-earnings, low price-to-book or high dividend yield ratios tend to outperform the broader market over multi-year periods. This is the "value premium."

The empirical record of real-world practitioners is equally compelling. Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway has compounded at roughly 20% per annum over six decades. The investment records of value-oriented managers like Seth Klarman, Joel Greenblatt, Walter Schloss and Howard Marks consistently demonstrate that patient, disciplined stock selection — focused on intrinsic value — outperforms index-tracking and most active management over long time horizons.

"In the short run, the market is a voting machine, but in the long run it is a weighing machine."

— Benjamin Graham

In the short term, prices are driven by sentiment, momentum, narratives and noise. In the long term, they converge on intrinsic value. Value investing exploits the gap between short-term sentiment and long-term reality — and that gap, driven by persistent human behavioural biases, shows no sign of disappearing.

The Australian Context: Why Value Investing Works Here

Australia's listed equities market offers a particularly fertile environment for disciplined value investors. Several structural features are relevant.

Franking Credits and Tax-Effective Returns

Australia's dividend imputation system — unique among major developed markets — means that dividends paid by Australian companies come with attached franking credits representing tax already paid at the corporate level. For investors in lower marginal tax brackets (including SMSFs in pension phase), this can generate significant additional after-tax return. A dividend with full franking effectively comes with a significant tax benefit — something most international investors cannot access.

Our SMSF management service places particular emphasis on maximising franking credit utilisation, because for many SMSF clients this represents a material, low-risk enhancement to returns.

Quality Businesses at Reasonable Prices

The ASX contains a number of world-class businesses — in resources, financials, healthcare, infrastructure and consumer staples — that periodically trade at valuations well below their intrinsic value. Our deep knowledge of these businesses, built over more than two decades, allows us to act with conviction when the market offers attractive entry points.

A Less Competitive Market

Relative to Wall Street, the Australian market is less heavily analysed — particularly in the mid-cap and small-cap segments. This creates more frequent mispricings that patient, thorough fundamental analysis can identify and exploit.

Common Misconceptions About Value Investing

"Value investing only works in bull markets"

The opposite is closer to the truth. Value investing's emphasis on margin of safety and downside protection means that value-oriented portfolios typically lose less in market downturns, while participating meaningfully in recoveries. The long-term compounding advantage comes partly from this asymmetry: losing less when markets fall is arithmetically powerful.

"Value investing means buying cheap rubbish"

Graham's original "net-net" approach — buying companies trading below the value of their current assets — was specifically designed for the information-poor, illiquid markets of the 1930s. Modern value investing, as practised by Buffett and many others, is focused on quality: buying excellent businesses at fair-to-attractive prices, rather than mediocre businesses at rock-bottom prices.

"Value investing is dead"

This claim surfaces every time growth stocks outperform for an extended period — as they did from roughly 2014 to 2021. It has never proved correct. Value investing's logic is rooted in permanent features of human psychology and market structure, not in any particular economic regime. When growth stocks eventually gave up their excess returns (as they began to do from 2022 onwards), value reasserted itself — as it always has.

What Value Investing Demands of Investors

There is no free lunch in investing — including in value investing. The approach demands real sacrifices, and understanding them upfront is important.

  • Patience. Value investment theses often take two to five years to fully play out. Investors who need short-term performance validation are poorly suited to the approach.
  • Contrarianism. Buying when others are selling — and sometimes holding while others are buying assets you don't own — is psychologically demanding, even when it is analytically correct.
  • Tolerance for short-term underperformance. There will be periods — sometimes extended periods — when a disciplined value approach underperforms a rising market led by momentum or growth stocks.
  • Rigorous analysis. Cheap stocks are often cheap for good reason. Identifying the difference between a genuine value opportunity and a "value trap" requires deep fundamental work.

These demands are significant. Many investors who embrace value investing intellectually struggle to maintain it emotionally through periods of underperformance. This is why having a trusted, experienced adviser — one who has managed through multiple market cycles — is so valuable. At Leyland, our investment team has navigated the dot-com bust, the GFC, the COVID crash and numerous other periods of market stress, maintaining discipline throughout.

Value Investing at Leyland: Our Approach

Our value investing approach combines Graham's foundational framework with insights from Buffett's quality-focused evolution and the realities of modern markets. In practice, this means:

  • Thorough fundamental analysis of every business we own, including company visits and regular management contact.
  • Insistence on a margin of safety in every purchase — we do not pay full price for any investment.
  • A preference for high-quality businesses — strong competitive positions, proven management, clean balance sheets — because these tend to compound value over time even if our initial entry price is not ideal.
  • Long holding periods that allow the full value of our investments to be realised without unnecessary transaction costs and tax friction.
  • Cash as a strategic tool — held when attractive opportunities are not available, deployed decisively when they are.
  • A global opportunity set — while many of our clients have strong preferences for Australian equities, we access international markets when the value case is compelling.

Learn More About Our Approach

Read about the principles that guide Leyland's value investing process — from rigorous research to margin of safety and downside protection.